6/25 SYTYCD 5 Results Are In for the Top 18

We have seen disappointment on this show repeatedly over the years, and we have watched it since year one. We go to see the show live each year, and are repeatedly stunned by the endearing personalities and inspiring talent of the dancers. So when we see any dancer that does not deserve to go home get eliminated, we are saddened.

When that dancer was part of a team that wowed us the night before and was clearly, if not the absolute best, among the best of the night, we are even more disappointed. And yet, we have yet to see what we considered the top three of either the male or female groups eliminated before the top 10. And we felt the same this week.

Still, last night, Randi and Evan were weak and were lucky. We believe it is their cute personalities and their humble origins that make them both way too lovable to vote against. Cuteness won out, and this couple was pardoned for a less than stellar evening last night. They escaped the bottom 3, but we think they deserved to be there more than one couple that was placed there and would eventually lose a dancer.

Caitlin and Jason were very weak last night in their Hip Hop routine. Jason was better, but wasn’t stellar. Caitlin has no feel for hip hop at all. But we feel that what transpired is ashame in a way, because we think that hip hop is the least important dance to master. Honestly, it is not in the same category as ballet, contemporary and ball room. This show has brought it to the forefront and made it entertaining, but to eliminate a dancer that is excellent because they cant “hit” a Hip Hop routine is sad. But would this doom them? Well, it did put them in the bottom 3.

Ashley and Kupono were also weak in their Hip Hop, and as we mentioned, when you get to go last, you have a chance to really nail the routine and get the most votes because the audience will remember you the best. The problem is, if you don’t, they remember that as well. Ashley and Kupono stepped out and embarrassed themselves. There was no style to their dance. It hit about as hard as a helium balloon. And the moves were as crisp as over-cooked spaghetti. Nothing about this performance did anything for us. In the other dances, one dancer was significantly better than the other. In this dance, neither did it for us. And they went to the bottom 3. So of the two soft Hip Hop performances, both couples were sent to dance for their lives.

max-ashleyKayla and Max performed one of the absolute best routines last night. Janette and Brandon were better, but there is no way this couple was in the bottom 3, and yet, there they were. America abandoned them. We expected Ashley and Kupono. We expected Caitlin and Jason. But Kayla and Max? No way. Compare them to any other couple last night and they were as good or better consistently than almost any of them. But America did them a disservice and placed them in a situation in which they had to dance for their lives.

Where does that logically place us? Well, Kayla is untouchable in our minds by the judges. They have promoted her too strongly, so if she didn’t fall down and hit her head on the stage, she wasn’t going to get sent home. That left either Caitlin or Ashley. It could have gone either way, but Caitlin’s solo was much better and that put the final nail in Ashley’s coffin. A sad ending to a great season and a horrible follow up to last week’s stellar performance. All primarily because of hip hop, a dance that, while fun, really is weak in the world of dance competition. Ashley is not the best of this group of women, but she did not deserve to go home yet, and it is pathetic that it is because of a hip hop routine.

Jason pulled out a spectacular solo and is amazing as a stand alone dancer. We would have been very upset if he had been eliminated as well because of being assigned a weak dance style. He wasn’t. He was great and the judges acknowledged it.

But what comes next is ashame no matter which dancer gets eliminated. Max was in one of the two or three best couples last night and shouldn’t even have to dance for his survival. And Kupono is an incredibly diverse and talented dancer. Kupono’s solo, though, was weak. He should have done much better. But the judges went for diversity over quality in this case and eliminated Max. Max was robbed because he should never have had to do a solo tonight. It was sad, but he wasn’t the man that was going to win this competition anyway.

FOX 11’s Jane Yamamoto reviewing the So You Think You Can Dance results show with Courtney Galiano

That said, two dancers departed that could not have been the winner of this year’s competition, so we don’t feel all that badly about their departure. However, we believe one was the luck of the dance draw and the other a victim of an audience that missed the performance.

We did pick two of the couples in the bottom three correctly. We do think Ashley lost the solo and thus was the correct gal to ship off. Max isn’t diverse enough. At best he is a Dmitri, a fourth place finisher. But we still felt he did not deserve it this week.

So, we were left a bit perplexed at one of America’s choices for the bottom three, but were in tune with the other two. We did expect Caitlin’s elimination, but could have seen either Kupono or Max go home.

The hardest thing now is it splits a couple. Max and Kayla were great together. Max is a great leading man for Kayla to follow on the floor. He has possibly the best partnering skills out of the group of men this year. As a result, Kayla has to dance with a partner with whom she is not familiar. And Kupono has a vastly different style. It could be very difficult for Kayla to get past that, and certainly it puts them at a severe disadvantage next week.

Couples who are safe and dancing next week:
max_ashley
Brandon and Janette
Karla and Jason
Evan and Randi
Ade and Melissa
Asuka and Vitolio
Philip and Jeanine

Bottom Three:

Kupono and Ashley
Caitlin and Jason
Max and Kayla

Eliminated: Max Kapitannikov and Ashley Valerio

Elimination Week Video Recap